Mitchell man sentenced to four years in prison after robbing local gas station

Geno Gehl has been sentenced to serve four years in prison after robbing the Easy Come & Easy Go gas station at gunpoint and stealing the BB gun from Cabela’s.

Police in Mitchell take two men into custody just two blocks away from the scene of an armed robbery at Easy Come & Easy Go on Thursday, Nov. 18, 2021. Hunter Dunteman / Mitchell Republic
We are part of The Trust Project.

MITCHELL – Geno Gehl, of Mitchell, has been sentenced to serve four years in prison after robbing the Easy Come & Easy Go gas station at gunpoint and stealing the BB gun from Cabela’s.

The 18-year-old and his accomplice, John Beck, 19, robbed the Easy Come & Easy Go gas station in November 2021, when Gehl held a clerk at gunpoint as they demanded the money in the cash register. Gehl's sentence was 10 years, with six years suspended.

Police arrested the pair after finding them on the street matching the gas clerk’s descriptions. The two were taken into custody after officers found $544 in cash on one of the men and two BB air pistols that mimicked the look of real guns.

A suspect is placed into the Mitchell Police Division squad car after an armed robbery was reported at the Easy Come & Easy Go gas station just minutes prior. (Hunter Dunteman / Mitchell Republic)

Gehl was charged with a first degree burglary, in which he pleaded guilty to.

Gehl confessed later that the attack was premeditated and his reasoning was that they needed gas money to get to Rapid City. He also confessed to holding the clerk at gunpoint and discharged the gun twice near the clerk in order to “hurry the clerk up”.


In his sentencing appearance on Tuesday, Gehl claimed his bad state of mind led him down an unfortunate path and he hopes to get the help he needs to improve his mental health status.

He also informed the court of his use of meth.

Judge Chris Giles pointed to Beck’s “criminal thinking” and planning he used to execute the robbery.

Judge Giles, however, expressed his concerns over how young Gehl is and the fact that he’s already committing violent crimes.

“I appreciate that you’re acknowledging that you had a mental health problem and drug problems,” Judge Giles said Tuesday. “However, the fact that this was premeditated is still concerning to the court.”

The judge sentenced Gehl to four years in prison with credit of 223 days served, a year less than Beck.

“You are young and I’m hopeful that you can use this as an opportunity to seek the help you need,” Judge Giles said after giving Gehl's sentence.

Cassie Williams joined the Mitchell Republic in July of 2022. To get in contact with Cassie about potential stories or ideas, feel free to email her at
What to read next
No updates on high school plans were expected, discussion likely to continue at Sept. 12 meeting
The driver lost control of the vehicle on loose gravel, causing the truck to roll.
‘We still have to provide decent facilities for our kids.’ Board members look ahead to big decisions
“Life sentences are reserved for the most heinous of crimes," said Deputy Attorney General Brent Kempema.