We see that you have javascript disabled. Please enable javascript and refresh the page to continue reading local news. If you feel you have received this message in error, please contact the customer support team at 1-833-248-7801.



Mitchell City Council rubber stamps permit for Kelley property to become wedding venue

“I know there are neighbors who have concerns. But whatever is out there will have to meet the city’s codes and requirements, including noise ordinances," said Don Petersen, a Mitchell attorney representing the buyer of the former Kelley property.

Shown here is the front entrance of the former Kelley house the a buyer is seeking to transform into a wedding venue.
Sam Fosness / Republic
We are part of The Trust Project.

MITCHELL — The Mitchell City Council paved the way for the former Kelley property to transform into a wedding venue after approving the buyer’s conditional use permit on Monday night.

Heading into Monday’s council meeting, the stakes of the decision for the conditional use permit were high. The still-anonymous buyer behind the $1.59 million approved offer on the property – which includes the 10,095-square-foot home and a large multi-use building – stipulated the conditional use permit for the wedding venue had to be secured for the sale to be finalized.

Although the buyer’s plans sparked opposition among some nearby residents who were concerned about the potential noise, traffic influx and public safety matters, the council unanimously approved the permit.

At the Sept. 12 city Planning and Zoning Commission meeting, over a handful of residents voiced opposition. That number depleted to just two residents who spoke at Monday’s council meeting.

Shirley Thompson, who purchased a property neighboring the former Kelley home, reiterated her concerns of the potential influx in traffic that the roads could see during weddings and how noise would be regulated.


“There is already a lot of traffic on those roads. We will have livestock on this property, and I have four children, and so if there is going to be partying until 11 p.m. at night I have some deep concerns,” Thompson said.

In the scenario a band was playing outside during a wedding, Mayor Bob Everson said a special event permit would be required for the band to play live music after 11 p.m. The city’s noise ordinance goes into effect at 11 p.m. and outlines the decibels that constitute as noise violations.

Don Petersen, a Mitchell attorney representing the buyer, sought to alleviate concerns and emphasized that any buildings on the property that transform into an assembly hall for weddings and events will be subject to meet the city’s building codes.

“I know there are neighbors who have concerns. But whatever is out there will have to meet the city’s codes and requirements, including noise ordinances. Once they have that (permit), they will move on to phase 2 which is designing what it will look like and present those plans,” Petersen said, noting the city’s building inspector would be tasked with signing off on the building plans and ensuring the city’s codes are met for assembly hall codes.

Shown here is the back of the Kelley home and the retractable roof portion of the house.
Adam Thury / Mitchell Republic

Loren Van Overschelde, a longtime nearby resident, brought forward some new concerns on Monday over what could happen if the property ceases to continue the wedding venue operation.

City officials explained the conditional use permit for the assembly hall is always attached to the buyer, meaning if the buyer sold the property, the new owner would be required to get their own conditional use permit.

Van Overschelde’s questions shifted more the discussion over to the zoning of the Kelley property and it being located adjacent to agriculture zoned districts in Davison County.

After annexing some of the Kelley property into city limits, the city rezoned the portion of the Kelley property into an Urban Development zoning district before selling the property to make it contiguous to an adjacent piece of land.


The council unanimously approved the $1.59 million offer on the Kelley home in June, which included around a dozen acres of land surrounding it and a large accessory building.

The buyer’s request for the conditional use permit came as no surprise to the council, as Brian Eliason, the Mitchell real estate agent facilitating the sale, explained the buyer’s contingency of securing the permit for the sale to be finalized.

Considering the immaculate home with a retractable roof and a heated driveway sat on the market for two years, paired with multiple price drops, selling the home has been a shared goal among city leaders.

Acquiring the home was not the intention of the city’s $4.1 million land purchase, which included 371 acres and the portion of the property with the home and multi-use building. The land buy was solely done for the upcoming wetland project that’s aiming to reduce the nutrient loads and runoff flowing into the lake via Firesteel Creek. However, the former homeowner stipulated the home must come with the land purchase.

With the council’s approval of the conditional use permit, it brings the sale of the home one step closer to being finalized.

Sam Fosness joined the Mitchell Republic in May 2018. He was raised in Mitchell, S.D., and graduated from Mitchell High School. He continued his education at the University of South Dakota in Vermillion, where he graduated in 2020 with a bachelor’s degree in journalism and a minor in English. During his time in college, Fosness worked as a news and sports reporter for The Volante newspaper.
What to read next
Watco purchased the former Mitchell-Rapid City Railroad in May 2021 and renamed it the Ringneck and Western Railroad. The line runs 108 miles from Presho to Mitchell where it connects with the BNSF Railway and primarily hauls grain, fertilizer and paper products.
A Class 3 felony is punishable upon conviction by up to 15 years in prison and a $30,000 fine.
Members Only
As part of phase II, the back nine of the 18-hole golf course will undergo major renovations and become a par-71 layout, dropping down from the existing par-72 setup.
If convicted and found in violation of his probation, Mason Buhl would face 225 years in prison and ordered to pay as much as $400,000 in fines.